Close this search box.

Substack vs Beehiiv vs ConvertKit – Which Newsletter Platform is For You?

Debating between Substack, Beehiiv, and ConvertKit for managing and monetizing your email newsletter? This article will help you pick the best platform for your needs.

Choosing between Substack, Beehiiv, and ConvertKit for your email newsletter platform is crucial for any writer or creator aiming to grow an engaged community and potentially monetize their content.

These platforms offer diverse features tailored to different needs, from straightforward writing and publishing on Substack to sophisticated email automation and segmentation with ConvertKit, and Beehiiv’s blend of newsletter growth tools and interactive experiences.

This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I receive a small commission at no cost to you when you make a purchase. This helps me pay to keep this site going and to bring all these free resources to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Substack vs Beehiiv vs ConvertKit: Breaking Down the Best Fit for Your Newsletter

Substack: Simplicity for Writers

Substack is celebrated for its ease of use, making it a favourite among writers and journalists. It provides a simple interface for writing, publishing, and monetizing through subscriptions, and it takes a 10% commission on earnings.

However, it lacks advanced marketing tools such as email automation and detailed analytics.

ConvertKit: A Marketer’s Dream

ConvertKit is tailored for creators who seek deeper engagement with their audience through automated email sequences, detailed analytics, and customizable sign-up forms.

READ  How to spot dodgy marketing (and avoid it)

Starting free for up to 1,000 subscribers, its pricing scales with your list’s growth, beginning at $29/month for more advanced features.

Beehiiv: The New Contender

Emerging as a strong competitor, Beehiiv offers a balance between ease of use and advanced features. It focuses on helping creators grow their audience through better analytics, recommendation engines, and a clean writing interface.

Beehiiv’s approach to community and interaction sets it apart, though it currently lacks the widespread recognition of Substack or ConvertKit.

Substack vs Beehiiv vs ConvertKit: Features Comparison

  • ConvertKit excels with its automation, segmentation, and integrations, perfect for creators needing detailed marketing tools.
  • Beehiiv emphasizes community building, offering features that foster deeper engagement with readers.
  • Substack prioritizes simplicity and direct monetization through subscriptions, suitable for writers focused on content rather than marketing complexity.
screenshot of James Sowers comparing Convertkit vs Beehiiv on X

(Source: @JamesSowers / X)

Substack vs Beehiiv vs ConvertKit: Pricing Models and Use Cases

PricingFree for up to 1,000 subs; paid plans start at $29/monthVaries; designed for scalabilityTakes 10% of subscription revenue
Best ForAdvanced email marketing and automationCommunity engagement and interactive newslettersStraightforward publishing and monetization

Substack vs Beehiiv vs ConvertKit – Which Should You Choose?

Your choice depends on your goals:

  • ConvertKit is ideal for those who prioritize email marketing sophistication and have a growth-oriented strategy.
  • Beehiiv suits creators who are focused on community engagement alongside growth.
  • Substack offers simplicity for writers eager to monetize without the fuss of complex marketing tools.

Your content’s success hinges on choosing a platform that aligns with your mission to deliver valuable, engaging content. Whether you’re a writer seeking simplicity or a creator needing robust marketing tools, there’s a platform tailored to your needs.

READ  Marketing case study: Panadol - Sell them what they want, then give them what they need

The key to success? Pick a platform and get started putting out regular content and building your audience!

Want more help with setting up your newsletter?

Check out this recording of a recent Linkedin Live event I hosted – Newbie’s Guide to Newsletters: Live Coaching with Ngoc Le. Click play to watch now.

Newbie's Guide to Newsletters: Live Coaching with Ngoc Le

Similar posts you might also like

B2B Marketing

Outsource LinkedIn Lead Generation: Options for Freelance Consultants on a Budget

Let’s dive into how startup freelance consultants can outsource LinkedIn lead generation in a budget-friendly way while maintaining quality and …

Read Article »
photo of man pointing at a map
B2B Marketing

Clarifying the Fractional CMO Scope: What to Expect

Unsure about what scope to expect from a fractional CMO? This blog post breaks down the fractional CMO scope and …

Read Article »
B2B Marketing

Should Cold Emails Include Images?

Cold emailing is a straight shot towards getting your message in front of the right eyes, but should you use …

Read Article »

Want more leads & sales?

How to Use Case Studies to Market Your Business

Build credibility & trust for your services. Join the training & download the PDF worksheet for free now.